State Loses All Three Preliminary Issues in Mundubile, Zulu Bail Fight
The Lusaka High Court has thrown out all three preliminary issues the State raised against the bail application of opposition leaders Mr Brian Mundubile and Mr Makebi Zulu. The ruling clears the way for the two men to seek bail in their sedition case, 85 days after they were…
The Lusaka High Court has thrown out all three preliminary issues the State raised against the bail application of opposition leaders Mr Brian Mundubile and Mr Makebi Zulu. The ruling clears the way for the two men to seek bail in their sedition case, 85 days after they were taken into custody.
The three-judge panel directed Mr Mundubile and Mr Zulu to apply for bail pending trial in the Lusaka Subordinate Court, where they are charged with seditious practices. Although the judges rejected the State’s objections, they accommodated the prosecution by taking judicial notice that the bail application should go to the subordinate court.
The State had raised three objections. It contended that the High Court could not hear the bail application while the substantive case was still before the Solwezi High Court, and that the filing amounted to a multiplicity of proceedings and an abuse of court process. It also said the applicants should first seek bail before the trial court in Lusaka.
The panel dismissed all three. It held that the court had jurisdiction to hear the application, and that there was no duplication because no bail application had been filed in Solwezi. It added that dealing with the matter in Lusaka would prevent unnecessary delay and promote the efficient administration of justice.
Lead defence lawyer Mr Sakwiba Sikota SC confirmed the outcome on the sidelines of the hearing and summed up what the ruling meant for his clients.
“In simple language the three preliminary issues the State raised have hit the dust,” Mr Sikota said. “It means we can now proceed for the Bail Application in the Subordinate Court before any further action soon.”
The senior counsel said the defence team was grateful the judges had thrown out the preliminary issues, because progress could finally be made. He also pointed to how long his clients have spent behind bars since their arrest in August.
“Justice delayed is justice denied and 85 days is more than a stretch even according to international law,” he said.
The sedition case dates back to 9 September, when police charged the two men with two counts of sedition. The charges relate to alleged Facebook posts and livestreams on 14 August, a day after the general election.
In the first count, Mr Mundubile is alleged to have called on the Electoral Commission of Zambia (ECZ) to declare the election winner based on parallel vote tabulation (PVT) results. Mr Mundubile contested the presidency on the National Reconciliation Party for Unity and Prosperity (NRPUP) ticket and belongs to the Tonse Pamodzi Alliance.
In the second count, Mr Zulu is alleged to have announced that Mr Mundubile would address the nation at a scheduled time. Both men deny the charges and are presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Their detention followed a raid on Mr Mundubile’s Kabulonga residence on 14 August. The pair then sought refuge at the United Nations buildings on Alick Nkhata Road.
They surrendered to police on 27 August under terms agreed between the UN Secretary General’s representative and President Hakainde Hichilema. Under those terms, the State pledged that the two would be subjected to the rule of law and full due process.
Two days later, the opposition figures were formally charged with treason and later moved to Mukobeko Maximum Correctional Facility in Kabwe, where they are held with 16 co-accused. The treason matter is separate from the sedition case, although both arise from the same post-election crisis.
The sedition proceedings began in Solwezi. The defence challenged jurisdiction there, telling the court that the alleged offences were committed in Lusaka and that both accused were arrested in the capital and live there.
On 5 November, Solwezi High Court Judge Edward Musona ordered the matter transferred to Lusaka. That transfer brought the case before the Lusaka High Court, and the State then raised the three preliminary issues that the panel has now dismissed.
The defence is now looking to a bigger decision in the treason case. The same three-judge panel will rule on Tuesday, 24 November on constitutional bail for all 18 accused.
“The big case is next week Tuesday when the three-judge panel makes a ruling on Constitutional Bail for all the 18 in the Treason case,” Mr Sikota said.
That ruling will decide whether Mr Mundubile, Mr Zulu and the 16 others are released on constitutional bail while the treason case proceeds. The 18 contend that their continued detention without trial violates their right to liberty under Articles 13 and 28 of the Constitution.
The State opposes their release, citing the seriousness and complexity of the charges, possible flight risk and public safety concerns. It says investigations are still ongoing.
Community Feedback