Police block term-limit marches as Kasonde warns democracy is on trial
Police block term-limit marches as Kasonde warns democracy is on trial – term limit marches blocked The Zambia Police Service has advised two civil society groups not to go ahead with planned processions over presidential term limits, drawing a sharp response from human rights…
Police block term-limit marches as Kasonde warns democracy is on trial – term limit marches blockedThe Zambia Police Service has advised two civil society groups not to go ahead with planned processions over presidential term limits, drawing a sharp response from human rights lawyer Linda Kasonde, who says Zambia’s democracy is now on trial. Lusaka Division Police Commanding Officer Ronald Zambo wrote to the organisers on 17 November, advising them not to proceed with marches planned for 25 November. He cited intelligence information and the prevailing national security situation. The advice covered Chapter One Foundation, which planned a procession opposing the removal of the term limit, and the Zambia Youth Organisations Consortium, which planned a march in support of removal. Both groups had notified the police of their plans weeks earlier.
“As you can see, our public institutions are on trial. Democracy in Zambia is on trial.”
Ms Kasonde, executive director of the LCK Freedom Foundation, said the country was witnessing a complete shutdown of the right to freedom of assembly for the first time in decades. She acknowledged that successive governments had used the Public Order Act against citizens and opposition parties. However, she said nothing in recent memory compared with what was happening now. She said the role of the police under the Act was to facilitate public demonstrations and keep people safe, not to stop them. She added that security reasons alone were not enough to prevent a protest from going ahead.
Ms Kasonde cited the Supreme Court decision in LAZ v The Attorney-General, SCZ Appeal No. 8 of 2014. That ruling confirmed the principle set in the earlier Christine Mulundika case that no permit is required to hold a public gathering. She said the court also held that if the police could not secure a crowd on a given date, they had to give reasons and offer an alternative date as soon as possible. Neither group has been offered an alternative date. Ms Kasonde said the law simply did not allow what the police were doing.
Governance and civil rights activist Brebner Changala went further. He said Government was using the police to intimidate citizens and that the blocked protests were not isolated security decisions. In his view, they formed a deliberate pattern to control public space, discourage dissent and keep citizens and opposition voices off the streets.
“Zambia is now a de facto police state.”
The sequence of events has also come under scrutiny. Chapter One Foundation, acting for a consortium of civil society organisations, notified the police on 2 November of a peaceful procession of about 500 people. Its notice offered around 25 marshals, cooperation on traffic management and the Freedom Statue as an alternative venue to Parliament. The youth consortium notified the police on 10 November of a march on the same date. Its vice-chairperson, Boas Kanyama, later claimed that 63,151 youths from across the country had confirmed their participation.
Constitutional law scholar Professor Cephas Lumina argues that the police decision does not meet the constitutional test of what is reasonably justifiable in a democratic society. He says the police letter came 15 days after the first notification and seven days after the second, without proposing another date. Under section 5(6) of the Public Order Act, as interpreted by the Supreme Court, police who cannot manage an assembly must give written reasons within five days and propose an alternative. Professor Lumina says calling the decision “advice” does not change its effect. He also asks why the police did not consider separate routes, different times or different venues for the two groups.
Not everyone agrees with the critics. Acton Institute for Policy Analysis Centre (AIPAC) executive director Solomon Ngoma said both organisations should comply with the directive, which followed an assessment of the national security situation. He said the groups should show responsibility by heeding police guidance while pursuing their positions on the constitutional question. Governance expert Kelly Mumba also urged compliance, warning that proceeding against police advice could affect public order and security. He said dialogue with the authorities offered a better way to deal with contentious national issues.
The dispute comes as debate over Article 106(3) of the Constitution intensifies. That provision bars anyone who has twice held office as President from standing again. Youths marched to Parliament on 27 October to call for its removal. Government has said that citizens remain free to express their views on the matter through lawful means. The two groups now face a choice between standing down and testing the police position before 25 November.
Community Feedback