Phase In FISP Loans Or Risk Mass Default, Chanda Warns Government
Former Member of Parliament Mr Sunday Chilufya Chanda has urged Government to pilot the new Farmer Input Support Programme (FISP) loan scheme with no more than a fifth of farmers before taking it national. He warned that switching all one million beneficiaries from grants to…
Former Member of Parliament Mr Sunday Chilufya Chanda has urged Government to pilot the new Farmer Input Support Programme (FISP) loan scheme with no more than a fifth of farmers before taking it national. He warned that switching all one million beneficiaries from grants to loans in a single season could end in mass default and wipe out the fund before it starts.
Mr Chanda said he fully backs turning FISP into a loan scheme, a model he says he pushed for while in Parliament. But he said the system is not yet ready to carry 1,024,434 farmers through the change at once, and that rushing it would repeat the failures of past Government lending schemes on a bigger scale.
“A loan that works for 200,000 farmers is better than a loan that fails 1,000,000,” he said.
Under the proposals in the 2027 Budget, Government will no longer give farmers fertiliser and seed as a grant. Inputs will instead be issued on credit and repaid after harvest, in cash or in maize depending on the final rules. A farmer who repays qualifies for the next season, while one who does not will be blacklisted. About K9.1 billion has been proposed for the scheme.
The former lawmaker was keen to correct confusion among farmers over timing. The loan system does not apply to the current 2026/27 season, which remains a grant. It begins with the 2027/28 season, when farmers plant in October 2027, once Parliament has approved the Budget.
By 6 November, 742,447 of the 1,024,434 farmers targeted this season had collected their inputs under the old system.
Mr Chanda said that leaves Government roughly 11 months, from November 2026 to September 2027, to publish guidelines, clean up the farmer register, train cooperatives and prepare written contracts. In farming terms, he said, that window is short because the rains cannot be postponed.
If the interest rate, repayment date, lending mechanism and drought provisions are still unknown by September 2027, he said, it would be unwise to roll the loan out to a million farmers at once.
His alternative is a three-stage roll-out. The first stage, in 2027/28, would cover 15 to 20 percent of farmers, about 150,000 to 200,000 people, in 20 to 30 districts. Ten would be districts with good rainfall, depots and extension services, and ten would be remote districts with poor rainfall and a history of late inputs, so the model is tested in good conditions and bad.
During that pilot, he wants Government to publish full guidelines before registration, issue contracts in local languages, test both cash and maize repayment, compare low and zero interest, and appoint an independent monitor.
The second stage, in 2028/29, would expand coverage to between 50 and 60 percent of farmers. It would also bring in banks, agro-dealers and aggregators under clear rules. A grant window would stay open for the elderly, widows, persons with disabilities and the ultra-poor.
Full national coverage would come in 2029/30, and only once repayment rates exceed 80 percent and both inputs and Food Reserve Agency (FRA) payments are arriving on time.
Mr Chanda said the phased approach also protects public money. If K9.1 billion is lent and half the borrowers default, K4.5 billion is lost in one season. A pilot of K1.5 billion, he said, would expose the flaws while saving K7.6 billion from the same mistake.
He said the case for moving away from grants is strong. FISP was designed in 2002 as a graduation programme to lift a farmer over three or four seasons and then make room for the next. Instead, he said, it became permanent.
“We turned a ladder into a chair. We sat on it for 24 years,” Mr Chanda said.
He said a grant is spent once and must be found again every year, while a repaid loan can serve farmers season after season. A loan also rewards productivity and gives farmers a credit history that can later support borrowing for pumps, hammer mills or transport.
His support, however, comes with seven conditions. Interest must be single-digit, fixed and written down. Repayment must follow the harvest and FRA payment calendar. A declared drought must lead to rescheduling or forgiveness, not default.
Contracts should be one page long and written in local languages such as Bemba, Nyanja, Tonga, Lozi, Kaonde, Lunda and Luvale. No farmer should be blacklisted without a hearing. In the long run, the scheme should also be open to civil servants who farm and should finance small-scale irrigation, not just fertiliser.
The former MP said farmers’ fears are well founded. Under a loan, a farmer carries the risk of drought, floods and armyworm alone. When inputs arrive late, harvests shrink while the debt stays the same.
He also pointed to fraud in the current system. The Auditor General found that 2,339 ghost farmers received inputs worth K19.6 million in 2025/26. Farmers now fear that cooperative leaders who abused grants could sign loans in their names, leaving them in debt for inputs they never received.
He said past schemes, including Constituency Development Fund loans, Citizens Economic Empowerment Commission (CEEC) loans and SAFF, failed partly because of drought, late inputs and late FRA payments, and partly because of a “Fya Boma” attitude that treats Government money as free. Both Government and farmers, he said, would have to change.
Mr Chanda drew a lesson from Nigeria. Its e-wallet programme sent vouchers to farmers’ phones to buy from private dealers and raised yields. Its later Anchor Borrowers’ Programme, which lent inputs and cash to smallholders, suffered heavy default, diversion and group blacklisting. Zambia, he said, should copy the first and avoid the second.
He said the scheme will succeed only if farmers can sell what they grow. He called on the Ministry of Trade and Export to negotiate formal government-to-government maize and mealie meal deals with the Democratic Republic of Congo and others, turning cross-border smuggling into taxed trade.
The FRA, he said, should announce a floor price before planting, pay on time and buy from cooperatives for export. He also wants the loan to finance crops beyond maize, such as soya beans, groundnuts, sunflower and cassava, according to each district’s soil and market.
“Without that ladder, a loan is just debt. With that ladder, a loan is capital,” he said.
Government has yet to publish the guidelines for the scheme. Mr Chanda said the details must come once the Budget is passed, and well before farmers sign for their first loan in September 2027.
Community Feedback