Monday, November 16, 2026

DPP Gilbert Phiri Loses Raid Video Fight As His Office Drops Sean Tembo Case

DPP Gilbert Phiri Loses Raid Video Fight As His Office Drops Sean Tembo Case
Music • Nov 13, 2026

DPP Gilbert Phiri Loses Raid Video Fight As His Office Drops Sean Tembo Case

Author

Breaking News Zambia

Music

Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Mr Gilbert Phiri, State Counsel, has lost a second courtroom battle in a week in the bail case of opposition leader Mr Brian Mundubile and 17 others. The Lusaka High Court refused his bid to remove video of the police raid on Mr Makebi Zulu’s…

Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Mr Gilbert Phiri, State Counsel, has lost a second courtroom battle in a week in the bail case of opposition leader Mr Brian Mundubile and 17 others. The Lusaka High Court refused his bid to remove video of the police raid on Mr Makebi Zulu’s Ibex Hill home from the court record.

In a separate courtroom, his office abandoned the insulting language prosecution of former Patriots for Economic Progress (PeP) leader Mr Sean Tembo. It did so before the court could rule on whether Mr Tembo had a case to answer.

Together, the two outcomes leave the chief prosecutor with little to show from a week spent largely on the defensive.

The video fight began when Mr Phiri and his team asked the court to expunge five paragraphs of the applicants’ affidavit in reply, numbers 6, 19, 20, 21 and 22, together with the flash disk holding the footage.

The prosecution argued that the material went beyond the proper scope of a reply and denied it a chance to respond. It also questioned the authenticity, origin and integrity of the recording.

The defence, including Mr Sakwiba Sikota, State Counsel, turned that argument around. The disputed paragraphs, counsel said, were a direct answer to the State’s own claim that Mr Mundubile and Mr Zulu were flight risks.

Any doubt over the video’s authenticity, the defence added, went to how much weight it should carry, not to whether it could be admitted. Counsel also told the court that a flash disk qualifies as a document under the Evidence Act.

The panel of Judge Derrick Mulenga, Judge Davies Chibwili and Judge Ireen Wishimanga rejected the core of the objection and admitted the video into evidence.

Paragraphs 19 and 20 stayed on the record because they answered the flight-risk allegation and raised no new issues. Paragraph 22 survived as well.

The DPP won only a partial concession. Paragraph 6 was struck out for introducing a new issue, and paragraph 21 for going beyond the matters the prosecution had raised.

Defence lawyer Mr Milner Katolo summed up the outcome for his clients.

The DPP’s preliminary issue had been dismissed, he said, and all the videos remain part of the evidence.

The footage had been a sore point from the start. When the objection was first raised, Mr Sikota said the prosecution appeared uncomfortable with a recording he said showed what happened when security officers raided Mr Zulu’s residence.

The ruling followed an earlier setback for the prosecution. Days before, the same judges threw out its first preliminary objection, which challenged the procedure the applicants used to file for bail, and held that the application was properly before the court.

At that stage the court also granted an adjournment so that Mr Phiri and Attorney-General Mr Mulilo Kabesha, both respondents in the case, could appear in person.

The objections fit a wider pattern. In the separate sedition case against Mr Mundubile and Mr Zulu, Mr Sikota complained that the State raises preliminary issues every time the matter comes before court.

The video ruling dealt only with the disputed material and did not settle the bail question itself.

The 18 applicants want to be released unconditionally or on reasonable conditions. They are also asking the court to declare that their prolonged detention without trial violates their constitutional rights.

The prosecution opposes bail. It argues that the seriousness of the charges and the possible sentences make suitable conditions difficult to set.

While the bail fight continued, the DPP’s office closed another long-running file.

State prosecutor Mr Michael Nundwe told the court that the Office of the DPP had filed a nolle prosequi in the Tembo case under Section 81 of the Criminal Procedure Code.

The notice came before Judge Chibwili, sitting as Lusaka Chief Resident Magistrate, could rule on whether Mr Tembo had a case to answer on two counts of using insulting language against President Hakainde Hichilema.

The judge admitted the nolle prosequi and discharged the former PeP leader, telling him he was “free to go home.”

The discharge is not an acquittal, and the DPP keeps the power to bring the charges again at any time.

The counts related to statements Mr Tembo allegedly made in Lusaka on 27 August and 17 October 2023. In September, Judge Chibwili refused to adjourn the trial, saying the matter could not be allowed to take three years to conclude.

Mr Phiri and Mr Tembo have crossed paths before. The chief prosecutor previously refused Mr Tembo consent to privately prosecute UPND Secretary General Mr Batuke Imenda, and also refused him consent to pursue a hate speech case against Education Minister Mr Douglas Syakalima.

Outside the courtroom, the treason case behind the bail fight also shifted.

Mr Katolo said retired Anglican Bishop Dr Trevor Mwamba and two other treason suspects were summoned to Police Service Headquarters. There, they gave ordinary statements in place of the warn and caution statements recorded from them earlier.

The change, he said, could mean the three are being turned into State witnesses or that they may be released. Their formal status remains unclear.

Reports circulated that the 68-year-old UNIP president would be freed from Mukobeko Maximum Security Correctional Facility for lack of evidence. No official confirmation had been issued at the time of publication, and Mr Katolo said Bishop Mwamba remains one of the 18 bail applicants.

On Monday, Mr Phiri returns to the Lusaka High Court to oppose the bail application of Mr Mundubile, Mr Zulu, Bishop Mwamba and the other applicants. The raid video he tried to remove will now be part of the record.

Related coverage from breakingnewszambia.com

Community Feedback

No approved comments yet.