Court Upholds NRPUP’s Lima Win as UPND Petitions Fail in Mpika North and Mwandi
The Lusaka High Court has upheld the election of National Reconciliation Party for Unity and Prosperity (NRPUP) candidate Mr Kelvin Kaunda as Member of Parliament for Lima Constituency. The court dismissed a petition by the losing United Party for National Development (UPND)…
The Lusaka High Court has upheld the election of National Reconciliation Party for Unity and Prosperity (NRPUP) candidate Mr Kelvin Kaunda as Member of Parliament for Lima Constituency. The court dismissed a petition by the losing United Party for National Development (UPND) candidate, Mr Lee Mukupa, finding no evidence to support his case.
Mr Mukupa had asked the court to nullify Mr Kaunda’s election over alleged electoral malpractice, including violence and undue influence. Delivering judgment, Justice Derrick Mulenga said the petitioner had lamentably failed to discharge the burden of proof required to nullify an election, because there was no tangible and cogent evidence to support the allegations.
The judge held that the people of Lima had clearly expressed their free will in the 13 August general election and that the result reflected their choice. He said the wide margin between the two candidates showed this: Mr Kaunda polled 22,760 votes against Mr Mukupa’s 8,041, a lead of 14,719 votes.
The Lima judgment adds to a run of failed UPND petitions. The High Court in Chinsali dismissed a petition against Mpika North MP Mr Francis Kapyanga, and the court also upheld the election of independent Mwandi Constituency MP Ms Iris Kaingu.
Justice Mulenga, the Judge-in-Charge of the Ndola High Court’s Industrial Relations Division, heard the Lima petition at the Lusaka High Court. During the trial, Mr Kaunda denied that widespread violence had marred the polls in the constituency and told the court there had only been isolated incidents.
The NRPUP lawmaker described his own movements on polling day. He said he voted at Ballastone Secondary School and later escorted NRPUP presidential candidate Mr Brian Mundubile, who belongs to the Tonse Pamodzi Alliance, to cast his ballot at Olympia Secondary School.
Mr Kaunda told the court that Lima had 13 polling stations and a voter turnout of about 47.7 per cent, and that no objections were raised after ballots were counted. He confirmed that he had received reports of UPND members assaulting NRPUP supporters in the Ballastone area on 10 July. He said he was not present and had been told three people were affected.
Mr Matthews Kangwa, a supervisor at Eden University, also gave evidence. He told the court that in July he saw three UPND-branded vehicles carrying about 12 people led by Mr Mukupa. He said workers at the university’s construction site were attacked that morning with pangas and stones, and that three of them, Mr Joseph Phiri, Mr Banda and Mr Sakala, were injured.
In his evidence, Mr Kangwa confirmed that Mr Kaunda is his employer at the university. He denied that this had shaped his testimony and told the court he held a permanent contract, unlike general workers, who are on two-year contracts.
The Mpika North petition ended the same way. Losing UPND candidate Mr Mordecai Sichalwe had accused Mr Kapyanga of vote-buying, intimidation and threats, which he said made it difficult to convince voters to support him.
The Chinsali High Court dismissed the petition and ruled that Mr Sichalwe had failed to prove the allegations of electoral malpractice, bribery and other irregularities to the required standard. Mr Kapyanga therefore keeps the Mpika North seat.
In Mwandi Constituency, Judge Willie Sinyangwe dismissed a petition by UPND candidate Ms Sibeso Sefulo against Ms Kaingu. The independent MP won 6,595 votes to Ms Sefulo’s 6,110, a margin of 485 and far narrower than the gap in Lima.
Ms Sefulo had alleged bribery, corruption and undue influence by Ms Kaingu’s agents, as well as procedural errors by the Electoral Commission of Zambia (ECZ). She also claimed that presiding officers had cast ballots for elderly voters against their wishes. The court found that she had not proved her allegations of bribery and other malpractice to the required standard.
Neither Ms Kaingu nor the ECZ testified during the three-day trial. Ms Sefulo has said she will take the matter to the Constitutional Court.
For now, Mr Kaunda, Mr Kapyanga and Ms Kaingu all keep their seats in the National Assembly.
Community Feedback